Book Review :: The Secret Scripture

Rosecommon Mental Hospital is the present day setting for Sebastian Barry’s novel The Secret Scripture. Alternating between two narrators – a 100+ year old woman / patient and her 65 year old physician – Barry goes back in Irish history to the days of Catholics vs. Protestants to weave his tale.

Roseanne has been institutionalized as long as anyone can remember, and with Rosecommon falling in on itself and just weeks from demolition, Dr. Grene must decide where to place Roseanne. All too familiar with the history of mental institutions and the way they’ve been used to lock undesirables away, regardless of true mental state, Dr. Grene sets out to discover why Roseanne is in Rosecommon.
At the same time, he is dealing with his own past and present – an apparent inability to connect with people, stemming from his own childhood as an adopted orphan, a distant marriage, and then the death of his wife that leaves him with huge grief and regret.
Orphans and institutions (orphanages, churches, asylums) are reoccurring elements through out the 80 years that the novel spans. In addition, themes of faithfulness, memory and truth play imperative roles as the past is revealed or uncovered. Roseanne tells of her relationship with her Protestant father – Joe Clear – a cemetery worker turned rat catcher; the local priest – Father Gaunt – whose peripheral presence throughout her life has great impact on her future; her husband – Tom McNulty – whose mother has their short marriage annulled; and Eneas McNulty – Tom’s vagabond brother with whom a one-night-stand proves enormously tragic.
Sounds wonderful, doesn’t it? For all the beauty in the concept, even in the characters, I was disappointed. Don’t get me wrong, The Secret Scripture is good, it just isn’t great. And, I felt this story had real potential, so I just felt let down reading it.
In addition, Barry pulls a fast one in the last 18 page of the novel, a twist that could only have been guessed in the last 50 pages and even then, it is a stretch to make it work. I don’t like writers who don’t respect their readers, and I felt a little betrayed by this one. It isn’t even that I didn’t like the ending – I thought it was a good way to bring the novel full circle and satisfy the mystery. I just didn’t like the way Barry did it.
So would I recommend The Secret Scripture? – to avid readers, absolutely – just don’t go in with the expectations I did and perhaps you’ll be pleasantly surprised.


Powered by Facebook Comments

5 Replies to “Book Review :: The Secret Scripture

  1. this has nothing to do with your post today, just a question… on your list of links of what you've read this year, some have the designation "(nf)"- what does that mean?

    Also, I happened to click on "The Middle Place" and saw that you wrote that post on my wedding day! Blasphemous! 🙂 just kidding, but when did you find the time?

  2. kjlanford – (nf) means nonfiction and (cl) means classic. At the beginning of the year I set goals regarding these two categories, and so this was my easy way of tracking. I did great on the nonfiction, but not so hot on the classics.

    I think I probably posted that entry while you were doing ballet! 😉 Also, a little secret of mine…sometimes I write posts & then schedule them to be published at a later time.

  3. What to do about this book? As I read your description, I started to wonder why I hadn't read this book already and why I'd actually never heard of it. I was thinking to myself, "Catholics, Protestants, and mental institutions? Yes, please." And yet, to learn that the author pulls a few fast ones, well that makes me cringe. I want to throw books that have such tricks in them across the room. Books like that make me even more grateful for the public library, as nothing irks me more than paying good money for a book that incites me to violence.

    So, here's what I'm going to do about this book – I'll keep it on my May Read Someday Pile. Thanks for your honest & insightful review.

  4. @Stacie – I thought the same thing!!! How has this one passed me by? Maybe just by knowing that there's a twist, you'll you be able to figure it out & not feel so betrayed. And please, no violence. 😉

  5. I think I liked this one better than you did. But maybe only because I am a real SB fan. Also, I saw the "surprise" coming a mile off, so didn't think it was sneaky and actually thought he did a nice job of developing the idea without either making it obvious or making it come out of thin air.

    Here is my review on Rose City Reader. I would like to list your review on my post. If that is OK with you, please leave a comment with a link on my review and I will add it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.